Why the Bengals Are the Worst Under-Center Offense in Football

By | Published: October 05, 2026 | 5 min read

Category: Player Analysis

Why the Bengals Are the Worst Under-Center Offense in Football

Yards a play from under center, all 32 teams, Bengals last at 3.3

What's going on

Cincinnati spent the offseason teaching Joe Burrow to take the snap under center. More play fakes, more tight ends, a run game that makes linebackers hesitate. The plan was simple: freeze the second level, then throw over it.

Four games in, the Bengals average 3.3 yards a play from under center. Dead last.

And they're doing it more, not less. Under-center snaps are up 54 percent from last year.

Here's what makes it strange. From the shotgun, this is a top-ten offense. Since 2024, only Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson and Brock Purdy have been worth more per throw from the gun than Burrow. On first and 10 the Bengals gain 7.4 yards a play out of the shotgun and 3.1 under center.

Same eleven guys. Same down. Same distance.

What it's costing them

Almost every under-center snap comes on first down, so every one of them is a first down they can't afford to waste.

The runs go nowhere. Chase Brown is at 3.4 yards a carry from under center and gets dropped at or behind the line on 23 percent of them (league average is 18). Nine runs aimed outside the tackles have netted seven yards. Total.

The passes go nowhere either. Eighteen throws, 2.7 yards a pop. The deep play-action shots this whole package exists to create are 1 for 4, and the best of them, a 33-yarder to Tee Higgins, got overturned on review.

The result: one under-center play in 67 has gone for 15-plus yards. The rest of the league hits one in twelve.

Most weeks, a first down under center is a punt with extra steps.

Why it's this bad

The target was fake. Last year the Bengals averaged about 5 yards a play under center, which is why anyone thought this was a good idea. Split that number by quarterback and it crumbles. Bengals yards a play under center by quarterback era

Joe Flacco, who has taken snaps under center since the Bush administration, filled in for seven weeks and averaged 7.5 yards a play from there. Brown ran for 7.1 a carry behind his play fakes. Every stretch without Flacco since 2024 lands between 2.3 and 4.1. Cincinnati built a plan around a mirage.

The run game is a line problem first. Brown hasn't forgotten how to run from under center. Over the last six weeks of 2025, with Burrow back, he averaged 4.7 a carry from the same alignment and got stuffed on 5 percent of his runs. Now it's 23 percent. Same back. Something in front of him changed, and the edges are where it shows.

The play calling pours gas on it. The Bengals run on 38 percent of first-and-10 snaps; the league runs on 53. So when this pass-happy team lines up under center on first down, it runs the ball 73 percent of the time. Defenses don't need the scouting report. They need the alignment.

The passing game takes away Burrow's best throw. This is the part that should keep Cincinnati up at night, because it isn't new. Joe Burrow EPA per pass by season, under center and shotgun, 2020 to 2026

Burrow used to be good under center. From 2020 to 2023 he averaged 7.1 yards a throw from there, better than he did from the gun. Then 2024 hit and the bar went red and stayed red. Since then he's the worst under-center passer in the league (35 quarterbacks with 60-plus attempts, and 26 of them are better under center than in the shotgun). Burrow trails the next-worst by a mile.

Eighty throws across three seasons. That's a pattern. And since it started in 2024, look at what changed around him, not at him.

Joe Burrow EPA per throw by depth, shotgun against under center, 2024 to 2026

From the shotgun, 39 percent of Burrow's throws travel 6 to 19 yards downfield. That's his bread and butter, and it's worth more than half a point every time he lets it go. Under center, that throw has all but vanished: 16 of them in three seasons. Seven in ten under-center passes travel five yards or less.

So Burrow gets two options from under center. A deep shot off a fake, or a checkdown. The middle of the field, the part he owns, isn't on the menu.

How they fix it

The run game should heal on its own. We found 19 teams since 2015 that started this badly under center, 40-plus snaps through four weeks. All 19 got better. As a group they jumped from 3.0 yards a play to 5.1, right at league average.

The 19 worst under-center starts since 2015 and what they did from week 5 on

Stuff rates drift back to normal. Brown's late-2025 run says the back is fine. Shore up the edges and this half looks better by November.

The passing half won't heal on its own, because nothing about it is bad luck. It's the menu.

Two ways out. Put the 6-to-19 yard throw back into the under-center calls, the way it was from 2020 to 2023. Or stop asking Burrow to throw from under center at all, and let the shotgun (where he's a top-five quarterback) carry the passing game.

After the Jaguars loss, Burrow said it himself: let's throw it more.

The data agrees. From the gun.

Numbers come from NFL play-by-play through Week 4 of 2026, with history back to 2015. "Under center" means the quarterback wasn't in the shotgun; kneels and spikes are removed. The quarterback comparison uses passers with 60-plus under-center and 200-plus shotgun attempts since 2024. Build your own chart at sticktothemodel.com/charting.