Drew Mestemaker
Scouting Report
A confident, big-armed gunslinger who plays fast.
The case for
- Quick release with easy velocity
- Deep and intermediate accuracy is the strength of his game
- Can change arm angle, shorten the delivery or add touch to fit tight windows
The worry
- Release starts low and the ball sails when he does not finish
- Turnovers come in clusters, with two interceptions in several games
- Arm confidence leads him to force throws into windows that are too tight
Full report
Drew Mestemaker is one of the most unusual evaluations in recent drafts: a zero-star walk-on who never started a varsity game in high school, played backup, punter and safety, and began at North Texas as a fifth-string quarterback. He led the FBS in passing in 2025 with 4,381 yards and 34 touchdowns against nine interceptions, then followed his head coach to Oklahoma State and answered the big question about his film by beating a top-ten team in his first Power Four start with his arm and his legs. At 6-3 and 215 pounds he has the size teams want, a quick release, easy velocity and real touch, and his deep and intermediate accuracy is the calling card. His feet stay connected to his eyes through the progression, he climbs past the first rusher, and he can reset after moving either way. He is mobile enough to extend plays and punish defenses that ignore him as a runner. The flaws are consistent across the reports: the release starts low and the ball sails when he does not finish, he hesitates on some middle-field windows, and arm confidence produces turnovers that come in clusters. He is also thin and needs functional weight. The crowd has him at the top of the class: most boards have him in the top five, with a few lower, and league personnel made him the leading quarterback in a midseason poll. He is a redshirt sophomore with eligibility left.
Every strength
- Feet connect to his eyes through the progression
- Climbs past the first rusher and keeps a throw alive
- Resets his base after moving left or right
- Extends plays and adds yards as a runner
- Fast internal clock fits timing-based offenses
Every weakness
- Hesitates on middle-field reads and throws late against the next defender
- Routine placement lags behind the difficult throws
- Thin frame needs functional weight to absorb NFL hits
- Mostly shotgun background leaves under-center footwork and play-action timing raw
- Not an elite runner
NFL Comps
The pros whose college production, size, testing and age looked most like his. The percent is how close.
Of his 20 closest coming out: 2 stars, 3 starters, 12 backups, 3 didn't stick.
Scouts say: Jordan Love.
Draft Movement
Up 16 spots since Jun.
Where he sits on the consensus big board, each week since Jun. Up is better.
The Tape
College Stats
| Season | Team | G | Cmp% | Yds | TD | INT | Y/A |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | North Texas | 14 | 65.7 | 4,189 | 31 | 9 | 8.9 |
| 2026 | Oklahoma State | 10 | 66.4 | 3,239 | 30 | 10 | 9.2 |
| Career | 24 | 66.0 | 7,428 | 61 | 19 | 9.0 |
From our play-by-play, so the yards can sit a touch under the official box score.
Strengths and weaknesses in the numbers
Where his 2026 season ranks among the 197 FBS quarterbacks who have played enough to qualify, through 10 games.
Where he stands out
- Passing yards per game: 324, 2nd of 197 (top 2%).
- Passing touchdowns: 30 in 10 games, 2nd of 197 (top 2%).
- Yards per pass attempt: 9.2, 12th of 185 (top 7%).
- Sack rate: sacked on 3.0% of his dropbacks, 17th lowest of 186 (top 10%).
From our play-by-play. Season totals are ranked per game. A number is listed only when it puts him in the top fifth or the bottom quarter of the group.
College Market Value
REPORTED Denton Record-Chronicle reported his deal at $3.75M for this season. Our model priced him at $6.00M before that report landed. UNDERPAID
The college fantasy model projects 21.1 PPG (QB2), after 27.0 PPG across 10 games last year.
Portal: transferred from North Texas to Oklahoma State for 2026.
Every P4 player priced, math public: College players & NIL · Roster spend
Awards & Honors
Burlsworth Trophy; American Conference offensive player of the year; AP national player of the week; QB1 in a midseason scout and executive poll with a record 17 votes
Drew Mestemaker 2027 NFL Draft profile
Our latest mock draft, November 19, 2026: pick 3 to the Miami Dolphins. See the Dolphins depth chart he would join, or the full mock.
Scouting report last written November 17, 2026. Consensus board last rebuilt November 16, 2026. Stats through 10 games of the 2026 season.
Where is Drew Mestemaker projected to go in the 2027 NFL Draft?
Drew Mestemaker is No. 7 of 725 prospects on the 2027 consensus big board. Projection: First round. Our own ranking has him No. 6. Our latest mock draft (November 19, 2026) has the Miami Dolphins taking him at pick 3.
How tall is Drew Mestemaker and what is his 40 time?
Drew Mestemaker is listed at 6-3 and 215 pounds. We do not have a verified 40-yard dash time for him yet.
Who is Drew Mestemaker's NFL comparison?
The NFL player whose college production, size, testing and age looked most like his is C.J. Stroud. The model puts his chance of becoming a 3-year NFL starter at 75%, from where he is projected to go and how the college careers most like his turned out. Scouting reports name Jordan Love.
What are Drew Mestemaker's strengths and weaknesses?
Strengths: Quick release with easy velocity. Deep and intermediate accuracy is the strength of his game. Can change arm angle, shorten the delivery or add touch to fit tight windows. Weaknesses: Release starts low and the ball sails when he does not finish. Turnovers come in clusters, with two interceptions in several games. Arm confidence leads him to force throws into windows that are too tight.


