John Mateer
Scouting Report
A gunslinging dual-threat passer who makes plays when it breaks down.
The case for
- Plus arm that can reach every level of the field
- Can fire throws into tight windows and push the ball vertically
- Throws a pretty deep ball, even when off balance
The worry
- Gunslinger mentality led to 11 interceptions in 2025 and some bad sacks
- Accuracy is streaky, and placement suffered badly after the thumb surgery
- Lacks anticipation and can fixate on his primary receiver, which lets defenders undercut throws
Full report
John Mateer is a dual-threat quarterback from Little Elm, Texas who went from a three-star recruit to Washington State's breakout starter, then followed offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle to Oklahoma. In 2024 he threw for 3,139 yards and 29 touchdowns and ran for 826 yards and 15 scores, which made him a Manning Award finalist. His Oklahoma debut opened with a program-record 392 passing yards against Illinois State. About a month into the season he broke his throwing thumb, and he came back only 17 days after surgery. His velocity and accuracy suffered, and he finished with 14 touchdowns against 11 interceptions while still getting the Sooners into the playoff. His best tape looks like a more athletic Baker Mayfield and his worst like a mid-round backup, and that spread defines his evaluation. Scouts like his arm, his deep ball, his toughness and his ability to extend plays. They also flag a gunslinger's mentality, streaky placement and a lack of anticipation. The 2026 film has not settled it. Against Michigan he went 17-of-33 with a touchdown and an interception, and at Georgia he went 25-of-34 with two touchdowns and an interception. Consensus boards currently project him in the seventh round.
Every strength
- Dangerous outside structure, with natural scrambling and the athleticism to turn broken plays into explosive ones
- Productive runner on designed quarterback runs, with 26 career rushing touchdowns
- Flexible arm angles help him in quick passing situations
- Tough competitor who played through a broken throwing thumb
- Projects well to an RPO-heavy NFL offense
Every weakness
- Pressure speeds him up and his footwork turns frantic
- Unconventional mechanics with a sidearm delivery on screens and rarely looks settled
- Less drive and velocity on cross-field throws outside the numbers
- Struggled against the biggest opponents, including Michigan and Georgia in 2026
- Needs to take checkdowns and throw the ball away more readily
Recruited
Class of 2022 · Quarterback · High school: Little Elm, TX
Partial offer list. Offer lists for the 2022 class are partial everywhere we can read them: we hold 3 or more offers for 165 of 2,212 recruits, and we grade only those boards.
College: Washington State 2022-24, Oklahoma 2025
NFL Comps
The pros whose college production, size, testing and age looked most like his. The percent is how close.
Of his 20 closest coming out: 4 stars, 5 starters, 8 backups, 3 didn't stick.
Scouts say: Baker Mayfield, Gardner Minshew.
Draft Movement
Down 270 spots since Jun.
Where he sits on the consensus big board, each week since Jun. Up is better.
College Stats
| Season | Team | G | Cmp% | Yds | TD | INT | Y/A |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Washington State | 5 | 73.3 | 217 | 2 | 0 | 14.5 |
| 2024 | Washington State | 12 | 62.5 | 2,968 | 29 | 5 | 8.4 |
| 2025 | Oklahoma | 12 | 58.3 | 2,745 | 15 | 9 | 6.5 |
| 2026 | Oklahoma | 10 | 64.5 | 2,153 | 15 | 7 | 7.2 |
| Career | 39 | 61.6 | 8,083 | 61 | 21 | 7.4 |
From our play-by-play, so the yards can sit a touch under the official box score.
College Market Value
Our model prices him at $1.98M on the open college market, built from production, pedigree, role and Oklahoma's program money. No credible deal has been reported for him this season.
The college fantasy model projects 13.4 PPG (QB44), after 16.5 PPG across 10 games last year.
Every P4 player priced, math public: College players & NIL · Roster spend
Awards & Honors
Manning Award finalist (2024); Earl Campbell Tyler Rose Award semifinalist (2024); Washington State team captain; Set Washington State quarterback rushing records (2024); College Football Playoff appearance (2025); District 5-6A Offensive Player of the Year and unanimous first-team all-district in high school
John Mateer 2027 NFL Draft profile
Scouting report last written October 19, 2026. Consensus board last rebuilt November 16, 2026.
Where is John Mateer projected to go in the 2027 NFL Draft?
John Mateer is No. 414 of 725 prospects on the 2027 consensus big board. Projection: Undrafted. Our own ranking has him No. 377.
How tall is John Mateer and what is his 40 time?
John Mateer is listed at 6-1 and 218 pounds. We do not have a verified 40-yard dash time for him yet.
Who is John Mateer's NFL comparison?
The NFL player whose college production, size, testing and age looked most like his is Sam Ehlinger. The model puts his chance of becoming a 3-year NFL starter at 11%, from where he is projected to go and how the college careers most like his turned out. Scouting reports name Baker Mayfield, Gardner Minshew.
What are John Mateer's strengths and weaknesses?
Strengths: Plus arm that can reach every level of the field. Can fire throws into tight windows and push the ball vertically. Throws a pretty deep ball, even when off balance. Weaknesses: Gunslinger mentality led to 11 interceptions in 2025 and some bad sacks. Accuracy is streaky, and placement suffered badly after the thumb surgery. Lacks anticipation and can fixate on his primary receiver, which lets defenders undercut throws.

