New: Be a GM College lets you run your NIL budget, fight the portal, and play the season. Try it. →
StickToTheModel
FreeMock Draft Simulator · seven rounds, trades, every pick graded as you make itStart a mock

Carter Smith

OT·Indiana·6-5·313 lb
First roundModel Score 91.7 A-four-star recruit
Updated November 21, 2026
#45
Consensus
STM #37
Draft him yourself → Player comps

Scouting Report

A polished, balanced left tackle with title-team film.

The case for

  • Quick, repeatable pass sets
  • Balanced feet and rarely on the ground
  • Cuts off speed without giving up the inside lane

The worry

  • Length is average to short for a tackle
  • Power rushers can get into his chest at times
  • Average lateral quickness against pure edge speed
Quick setsBalanceStarting experienceArm lengthWide speedGrabby hands
Full report

Smith is a polished left tackle with more than 40 straight starts at Indiana and a national title on his resume. At 6-foot-5 and 313 pounds, he wins with quick, repeatable sets, balanced feet and disciplined hands. A four-star Ohio recruit, he redshirted in 2022, took over at left tackle in 2023, earned honorable mention All-Big Ten in 2024, then became a consensus All-American and the Big Ten's top offensive lineman in 2025. He returned from labrum surgery in his left shoulder without missing a start and has allowed just six pressures through nine games this fall. Pass protection is the headliner: he cuts off speed without giving up the inside lane and rarely ends up on the ground. As a run blocker he climbs to linebackers with balance and finishes on screens, though some want more displacement at the point of contact. The concerns are physical. His length is average at best for a tackle, power rushers can get into his chest at times, and pure edge speed can test his lateral range. He also gets grabby when beaten and has drawn three flags this season. Evaluators are split on his home: most see a starting left tackle, while a few think his hands and strength fit best at guard. Most boards have him in the early second round, with the high end seeing a first-rounder.

Every strength

  • Six pressures allowed in nine games this season
  • Over 40 straight starts at left tackle with no games missed to injury
  • Climbs to linebackers and leads on screens under control
  • Consistent hand use and competitive toughness through the rep
  • Consensus All-American and Big Ten top lineman on a national champion

Every weakness

  • Reaching with the hands or first step exposes the inside counter
  • Grabby when threatened, with three flags this season
  • Labrum repair in his left shoulder will get a close look at the combine
  • All of his film comes from one scheme and one line coach
  • Run-game displacement at the point of contact is still questioned

Recruited

Class of 2022 · Offensive tackle · High school: Olentangy Liberty, Powell, OH

Recruiting sites
★★★★★
No. 730 in the nation. Composite 0.8724, the recruiting sites' average
Offers
Partial list
None on record beyond his commitment

Partial offer list. Offer lists for the 2022 class are partial everywhere we can read them: we hold 3 or more offers for 165 of 2,212 recruits, and we grade only those boards.

College: Indiana 2022-25

Every recruit in the 2022 class →

NFL Comps

The pros whose college production, size, testing and age looked most like his. The percent is how close.

Of his 20 closest coming out: 1 star, 5 starters, 12 backups, 2 didn't stick.

Scouts say: Jonah Williams, Greg Little.

Draft Movement

Down 24 spots since Jun.

#20#30#40#50#60#45JunJulAugSepOctNov

Where he sits on the consensus big board, each week since Jun. Up is better.

The Tape

Indiana Hoosiers vs. Purdue Boilermakers | COLLEGE FOOTBALL HIGHLIGHTS | 11/28/2025 | NBC Sports

NBC Sports·112K views

Jeremiah Smith's Best Plays From The 2025 Season | College Football Highlights

B/R CFB·13K views

Carter Smith vs Ohio State 2025 B1G Champ

Cam Cut-Ups·646 views

Carter Smith, Indiana Breakdown | Top-10 OTs in College Football

Carter Smith 2025 Season Cut-Up | Indiana Junior OT

College Stats

2022: redshirt, 2 games; 2023: 12 starts at LT; 2024: 13 starts at LT; 2025: LT starter on the national title team; 2026: 40+ straight starts, 6 pressures allowed in 9 games

College Market Value

Model price$1.59M
Reported dealnone this season

Our model prices him at $1.59M on the open college market, built from production, pedigree, role and Indiana's program money. No credible deal has been reported for him this season.

Every P4 player priced, math public: College players & NIL · Roster spend

Awards & Honors

2025 CFP national champion, consensus All-American, first-team All-Big Ten, Big Ten Offensive Lineman of the Year (Rimington-Pace), Outland Trophy finalist; 2024 honorable mention All-Big Ten; early second round on most boards

Carter Smith 2027 NFL Draft profile

Consensus rank#45 of 725
Our rank#37
Position rankOT6 of 37
Model Score91.7 A-
ProjectionFirst round
Height6-5
Weight313 lb
Age on draft day23.0
Closest NFL compMichael Deiter

Our latest mock draft, November 19, 2026: pick 34 to the Miami Dolphins. See the Dolphins depth chart he would join, or the full mock.

Scouting report last written November 16, 2026. Consensus board last rebuilt November 16, 2026.

Where is Carter Smith projected to go in the 2027 NFL Draft?

Carter Smith is No. 45 of 725 prospects on the 2027 consensus big board. Projection: First round. Our own ranking has him No. 37. Our latest mock draft (November 19, 2026) has the Miami Dolphins taking him at pick 34.

How tall is Carter Smith and what is his 40 time?

Carter Smith is listed at 6-5 and 313 pounds. We do not have a verified 40-yard dash time for him yet.

Who is Carter Smith's NFL comparison?

The NFL player whose college production, size, testing and age looked most like his is Michael Deiter. The model puts his chance of becoming a 3-year NFL starter at 60%, from where he is projected to go and how the college careers most like his turned out. Scouting reports name Jonah Williams, Greg Little.

What are Carter Smith's strengths and weaknesses?

Strengths: Quick, repeatable pass sets. Balanced feet and rarely on the ground. Cuts off speed without giving up the inside lane. Weaknesses: Length is average to short for a tackle. Power rushers can get into his chest at times. Average lateral quickness against pure edge speed.