New: Be a GM College lets you run your NIL budget, fight the portal, and play the season. Try it. →
Week 9 · Saturday, October 31 · 3:45 PM ET

Utah at Cincinnati

Utah -6.5At Cincinnati · Big 12
Total 55.5
The story

The script. The market has Utah by 6.5 at a total of 55.5: Utah 31, Cincinnati 24.5 on paper. Utah ahead means Parker carries it late; Cincinnati chasing means O'Brien throws, and Gibson and Johnson get the volume.

How it plays. The total of 55.5 is ordinary for college. Conference play.

What changed. No injury report or depth chart for college yet; the names above are the last ones we saw carrying it.

The read

Utah is favored by 6.5 on the road against Cincinnati, and the total is 55.5. Our number has Utah by 11.2, so the lean is Utah -6.5. A lean, not a play.

Spread
Utah -6.5
Cincinnati +6.5
Total
55.5
Over and under
Moneyline
Cincinnati +195
Utah -238

Our number vs the market

The lean
Utah -6.5
A lean, not a play
Our number
Utah by 11.2
Market has Utah -6.5
Gap
4.7 pts
Between our number and the market

College is leans only. The model has no proven edge against the spread here, so this is where we disagree with the market, not a bet we are telling you to make.

The card

Nothing on the college card for this game yet.

Two registered rules, graded in public after each game: a player under when his line sits 50% or more above his last-10 average, and a total when our Sunday number sits 3 or more points off the opener. The kinds grade beside each pick counts the different kinds of evidence that agree: a rule, his history, the matchup, the script, the weather.

Where the money is

Bets is the share of tickets; money is the share of dollars. When the money runs well ahead of the bets, fewer people are betting bigger on that side, the move bettors call sharp money.

Spread

Utah-7+7Cincinnati
Bets50%50%
Money26%74%

50% of the bets are on Utah, but 74% of the money is on Cincinnati.

Since 2018: when most of the bets sat on one side and most of the money on the other, the money side covered 50% (583-582-20, 1,185 games). No better than a coin flip.

Bets and money splits via DraftKings, as of Sun 5:05 PM ET. One book's customers, not the whole market.

Who carries it
Utah
  • QB Devon Dampier 224 passing yards a game in 4 games, 205 last season
  • RB Wayshawn Parker 82 rushing yards a game in 4 games, 72 last season
  • RB Daniel Bray 25 rushing yards a game in 4 games, 30 last season
  • WR Braden Pegan 66 receiving yards a game in 4 games
  • WR Creed Whittemore 33 receiving yards a game in 4 games, 18 last season
  • WR Ricky Johnson 25 receiving yards a game in 4 games
Cincinnati
  • QB Liam O'Brien 18 passing yards a game in 1 game
  • RB Gi'Bran Payne 78 rushing yards a game in 5 games
  • RB Cole Tabb 65 rushing yards a game in 5 games
  • WR JaVonnie Gibson 53 receiving yards a game in 5 games
  • WR Isaiah Johnson 28 receiving yards a game in 5 games, 18 last season
  • WR Malachi Henry 28 receiving yards a game in 5 games

From the game logs, this season first. College has no published depth chart or injury report; these are the players who actually carried it.

The game plan
Utah with the ball

What they like to do. Utah play fast (12th) and run it more than almost anyone (22nd-lowest).

Where they win and lose. They run it well (8th), break explosive runs (10th) and move the ball (12th).

What the Cincinnati defense brings. They never take it away (3rd-worst).

What works against them. Nothing on the ledger stands out.

Where the two meet. No strength meets a weakness here; it comes down to talent, and the power gap says who has it.

Cincinnati with the ball

What they like to do. Cincinnati play slow (5th-slowest).

Where they win and lose. They protect the quarterback (4th), move the ball (6th) and break explosive runs (6th).

What the Utah defense brings. They get sacks (20th) and they give up the run (7th-worst).

What works against them. Nothing on the ledger stands out.

Where the two meet. Cincinnati protect the quarterback (4th); Utah get sacks (20th). Strength on strength, the matchup to watch.

From every play of the 2025 season, ranked against the 138 FBS teams. College has no blitz or coverage charting yet, so the plan reads strengths against weaknesses.

Head to head since 2013

Cincinnati 0-1 in the series over these 1 games.

2025-11-01Cincinnati 14 at Utah 45Utah covered, Utah -11