New: Be a GM College lets you run your NIL budget, fight the portal, and play the season. Try it. →
StickToTheModel
FreeBe a GM · run the cap, the cuts, the trades and the draft for your teamRun the team

Kool-Aid McKinstry

CB·New Orleans Saints
Tier 7Round 2, pick 41 in 2024
Updated November 21, 2026
76.4
Model Score
Down from 86.2 last year
Trade value ·a 6th

Kool-Aid McKinstry has 0 interceptions, 6 pass deflections and 56.8% completion rate allowed in 9 games for the New Orleans Saints this season through Week 10 (updated November 21, 2026).

Model Score by season

Down 9.8 from last season.

6070809076.4202420252026

How good he is at what he is supposed to be doing, out of 100. Not a projection of what he will do next, and not a read on his contract. Median is about 70, and a 95 is rare. How it is built →

STM Take

A young corner climbing the ladder a rung at a time.

The case for

  • Alabama SEC 2023 First-Team All-SEC honors plus the 41st overall draft slot establishes real elite college foundation.
  • 21-spot year-over-year improvement from tier 8 (#72) rookie to tier 7 (#51) sophomore shows developmental trajectory.

The worry

  • Tier 7 (#51) sophomore finish for a 41st overall pick is below the year-two median for 2nd-round CB prospects on Pro Bowl trajectories.
  • New Orleans's broader defensive identity transition plus the multi-year QB rebuild compresses the structural support around McKinstry.

What to watch: Whether McKinstry crosses into tier 5 (top 40) in 2026, the standard year-three threshold for 2nd-round CB picks on Pro Bowl trajectories.

Full take and bio

Tier 8 (#72) rookie to tier 7 (#51) sophomore for a 41st overall 2nd-round pick puts McKinstry on the year-two developmental band. The Alabama SEC pedigree plus the structural Saints anchor role gives him real college foundation. The 2026 question is whether McKinstry crosses into tier 5-6 territory in his year-three jump or whether the structural tier 7 finish becomes the realistic baseline.

McKinstry came out of Alabama as the New Orleans Saints' 2nd-round pick (41st overall) in 2024 after winning the 2023 SEC Championship plus earning First-Team All-SEC honors. He spent his rookie year as developmental depth before emerging into a starter role in 2025. His STTM career runs tier 8 (#72) rookie to tier 7 (#51) sophomore, a 21-spot improvement still on the developmental band.

Comps

The players whose size, testing and production looked most like his at the same point in their careers. The percent is how close.

Plays like: Darrell Baker, A.J. Bouye, De'Vante Bausby. Built like: Caelen Carson, Nohl Williams, Craig Mager. Coming out: Tyrique Stevenson, Daxton Hill, Kristian Fulton.

Of his 20 closest coming out: 4 stars, 5 starters, 9 backups, 2 didn't stick.

Kool-Aid McKinstry Injury StatusNot listed

Kool-Aid McKinstry is not on the injury report as of Nov 21. Source: the official NFL injury report, refreshed daily.

This season · 9 games

INT048th
Pass Deflections640th
Comp % Allowed56.8%52nd
Yds / Target8.989th
TD Allowed257th
Solo Tackles2057th

Every game on the Game Log, every season on Career. Advanced numbers are EPA and Next Gen Stats.

Contract2026 cap

2026 Cap Hit
$2.5M
APY
$2.3M/yr
Guaranteed at Signing
$7.3M
Years on Deal
4
Signed
2024
Est. Value
$12.5M/yr
underpaid by $10.2M/yr

Every year of the deal, the dead money and what a cut or trade saves on the Contract tab.

Draft & College

Round 2, pick 41 to the New Orleans Saints in 2024, out of Alabama (SEC). He went about where consensus had him.

Taken#41
Consensus board28th
Our college model#529 CB

In college, 2021-2023, 42 games: 2 INT, 20 pass breakups, 92 tackles, 5 TFL.

Recruited

Class of 2021 · Cornerback · High school: Pinson Valley, Pinson, AL

Recruiting sites
★★★★★
No. 18 in the nation. Composite 0.9906, the recruiting sites' average
Offers
Partial list
None on record beyond his commitment
Committed to

Partial offer list. Offer lists for the 2021 class are partial everywhere we can read them: we hold 3 or more offers for 43 of 3,366 recruits, and we grade only those boards.

College: Alabama 2021

Every recruit in the 2021 class →

Related Tools & Pages