Which NFL teams draft best?
Every pick since 2012, graded on what the player became.
The Saints, Lions and Cowboys draft best since 2012. The Vikings draft worst.
The tick on each bar is the league: 44% of picks beat their slot. Late finds are stars picked in round 4 or later.
How it works: every pick is compared with what its draft slot usually produces. A hit beat the slot. A star had a season in the top 10% at his position. An early bust is a round 1 to 3 pick who never produced. The letter blends value over the slot, starters, stars and early busts. A best season counts only after 16 games, and the last two classes are still developing.
A first-rounder becomes a star 37% of the time. A seventh-rounder, 2%.
First-round cornerbacks bust 32% of the time. Safeties, 8%.
First-round trade-ups became stars 38% of the time. Picks that stayed put, 40%.
Picks who tested 8.5 and up became stars 23% of the time. Under 3, 12%. Inside the same round, most of that gap disappears.
Athletic score: combine size, speed, explosion and agility against every player at his position since 2000, 0 to 10.
The Eagles draft the best testers (average 6.7). The Rams the worst (5.3).
Ranked by how far their picks beat the draft slot, same as the GM grades page
- BBBrandon BeaneBills, 2018 to 2025 · 64 picks · 61% of picks beat their slot1
- RPRyan PaceBears, 2015 to 2021 · 46 picks · 57% of picks beat their slot2
- JLJohn Lynch49ers, 2017 to 2025 · 77 picks · 51% of picks beat their slot3
- BGBrian GutekunstPackers, 2018 to 2025 · 80 picks · 55% of picks beat their slot4
- GPGeorge PatonBroncos, 2021 to 2025 · 38 picks · 50% of picks beat their slot5
- BVBrett VeachChiefs, 2018 to 2025 · 55 picks · 55% of picks beat their slot6
- OKOmar KhanSteelers, 2023 to 2025 · 21 picks · 53% of picks beat their slot7
- BHBrad HolmesLions, 2021 to 2025 · 36 picks · 52% of picks beat their slot8
Pick a team for who ran each draft, the best picks and the misses
Which NFL team drafts best?
Since 2012, the New Orleans Saints, Detroit Lions and Dallas Cowboys grade best on what their picks became: the Saints hit on 45% of picks against a league average of 44%. The Minnesota Vikings grade worst.
How are NFL drafts graded here?
Every pick is compared with what its draft slot usually produces, using each player's best season as a percentile at his position. The grade blends value over the slot (35%), starters (25%), stars (25%) and early-round busts (15%), each against the league average.
Do NFL teams that trade up in the draft do better?
Not in the first round. First-round trade-ups became stars 38% of the time, picks that stayed put 40%, and picks that came from trading down 25%.
Rates by round and position use drafts through 2022, so every player has had three seasons.