Brett Toth
San Francisco 49ersSeason Stats · 11 games
Draft & College
STM Take
First STTM ranking at tier 4 (#27) as a 2018 service-academy UDFA in year eight is the kind of late-career outlier that defines journeyman trajectories. The Army background plus the Eagles' position-specific coaching reputation appears to be the catalyst. The 2026 question is whether Toth holds tier 5 or better across a full second starter season or whether 2025 was a one-year context-driven peak.
Toth came out of Army as a 2018 undrafted free agent who entered the league through the service-academy military waiver process. He has been a journeyman interior lineman across multiple teams, taking spot reps and depth roles before landing with the Philadelphia Eagles. His first STTM appearance comes in 2025 at tier 4 (#27), an unusual late-career emergence for a former service-academy UDFA.
Strengths
- First sustained NFL starter season ending in tier 4 (#27) for a service-academy 2018 UDFA puts him in the rarest outlier-positive class at the position.
- Eagles' position-specific offensive line coaching reputation creates the structural environment that captures depth-piece ceiling.
Concerns
- Single tier 4 finish without prior STTM history caps the long-term projection certainty almost entirely.
- Service-academy UDFA pedigree plus eight years of journeyman travel pattern means the 2025 starter window may not extend.
What to watch: Whether Toth holds 8 or more starts in 2026 or whether the role compresses back to swing-guard depth.