Mock Draft Scoreboard · The Draft Network

Justin Melo graded 24.8% on the 2025 draft

T-38 of 51 first-round mocks. Unranked on career until a third draft is on file.

Every draft on file

Draft	Finish	Score	Exact	Within 3	Right team	First-rounders	Mania pts
2025	T-38 of 51	24.8%	5	7	4	26/32	119

2025, pick by pick

Graded on the mock on Justin Melo's own page, published April 23, 2025, before the first pick, read by us on November 13, 2026. The Internet Archive kept a copy from before the draft.

Pick	Mocked	Actually went	Pts
1	Cam Ward to TEN	Cam Ward to TEN	120
2	Travis Hunter to CLE	Travis Hunter to JAX	88
3	Abdul Carter to NYG	Abdul Carter to NYG	120
4	Jalon Walker to NE	Will Campbell to NE	8
5	Ashton Jeanty to CHI	Mason Graham to CLE	40
6	Armand Membou to LV	Ashton Jeanty to LV	32
7	Mason Graham to NYJ	Armand Membou to NYJ	40
8	Shemar Stewart to CAR	Tetairoa McMillan to CAR	8
9	Tetairoa McMillan to NO	Kelvin Banks to NO	40
10	Tyler Warren to JAX	Colston Loveland to CHI	16
11	Will Johnson to SF	Mykel Williams to SF	0
12	Matthew Golden to DAL	Tyler Booker to DAL	0
13	Jahdae Barron to MIA	Kenneth Grant to MIA	0
14	Colston Loveland to IND	Tyler Warren to IND	16
15	Mike Green to ATL	Jalon Walker to ATL	16
16	Mykel Williams to ARI	Walter Nolen to ARI	24
17	Derrick Harmon to CIN	Shemar Stewart to CIN	0
18	Grey Zabel to SEA	Grey Zabel to SEA	112
19	Jihaad Campbell to TB	Emeka Egbuka to TB	8
20	Shedeur Sanders to NYG	Jahdae Barron to DEN	0
21	Kenneth Grant to PIT	Derrick Harmon to PIT	16
22	Omarion Hampton to LAC	Omarion Hampton to LAC	120
23	Will Campbell to GB	Matthew Golden to GB	0
24	Malaki Starks to MIN	Donovan Jackson to MIN	40
25	Emeka Egbuka to HOU	Jaxson Dart to NYG	0
26	Josh Conerly to LAR	James Pearce to ATL	32
27	Donovan Ezeiruaku to BAL	Malaki Starks to BAL	8
28	Maxwell Hairston to DET	Tyleik Williams to DET	32
29	Oluwafemi Oladejo to WAS	Josh Conerly to WAS	0
30	Trey Amos to BUF	Maxwell Hairston to BUF	16
31	Kelvin Banks to KC	Jihaad Campbell to PHI	0
32	Walter Nolen to PHI	Josh Simmons to KC	0

How a mock is scored. Every pick is worth up to 120 points, and a mock's score is the share of the points it was playing for, so a 32-pick first round and a full seven rounds compare directly.

64 pts: the player went at exactly that pick
32 pts: he went within three picks of it
32 pts: right player to the right team, wherever he actually landed
16 pts: right position to the team that was on the clock
8 pts: right order inside a position: the fourth quarterback is the fourth quarterback

Trades are not penalised. A pick is graded against whoever ended up making it, which is why "right position to the team on the clock" is a separate line from "right player to the right team." A mock only counts if its own page shows it was published before the first pick; anything filed after that is a recap. Positions come from the official draft listing, so every mock is graded on the same labels.

Two more numbers sit beside the grade and do not change it. First-rounders named is how many of the players in the mock went in round one at all, wherever the mock had them. Mania points is the same mock on the scale our Mock Draft Mania contest uses for fans: 1 point for a player who went in round one, 2 for a top-ten pick who went top ten, 3 for a top-five pick who went top five, 5 for the right team and 10 for the exact pick.

1 draft on the record

Best round on file: 24.8% in 2025. Across every draft graded here, 5 picks exactly right out of 32. Round 1 only.

Scored the same way as every other mock on the Mock Draft Scoreboard. Think you can beat it? Build one in our simulator and we will grade yours next April.

Every draft graded: 2026 2025 2024 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019

Run your own mock →