New: Be a GM College lets you run your NIL budget, fight the portal, and play the season. Try it. →
StickToTheModel
FreeBe a GM · run the cap, the cuts, the trades and the draft for your teamRun the team

Colton McKivitz

LT·San Francisco 49ers
UNDERPAIDTier 1Round 5, pick 153 in 2020
Updated November 22, 2026
85.0
Model Score
Down from 85.8 last year
Trade value ·a late 1st

Colton McKivitz has 78.8 pass protection grade, 66.1 run blocking grade and 74.9 overall grade in 7 games for the San Francisco 49ers this season through Week 10 (updated November 22, 2026).

Model Score by season

Down 0.8 from last season.

70809085.02023202420252026

How good he is at what he is supposed to be doing, out of 100. Not a projection of what he will do next, and not a read on his contract. Median is about 70, and a 95 is rare. How it is built →

STM Take

A steadily improving right tackle who has become a reliable starter.

The case for

  • Three straight seasons of STTM improvement (#52, #47, #29) confirms the year-over-year development is real. 5th-round draft pedigree to tier 4 starter is meaningful value.
  • West Virginia starter pedigree (35+ college starts) plus three years of NFL swing-tackle reps gave him the technical foundation when the starter role opened in 2023.

The worry

  • Three years of starter snaps without a tier 2-or-better finish shows the ceiling may be tier 4 rather than a true mid-tier RT.
  • Trent Williams's eventual retirement plus the 49ers' offensive line transition compresses McKivitz's structural position long-term.

What to watch: Whether McKivitz sustains his 2025 tier 4 (#29) baseline in 2026 or whether the regression pulls him back to tier 6 territory.

Full take and bio

Three consecutive years of STTM improvement (#52, #47, #29) is the textbook developmental arc for a 5th-round value pick stepping into a full-time starter role. Trent Williams's continued LT presence plus Christian McCaffrey's pass-protection demands keeps the offensive line identity strong, which lifts McKivitz's individual production. At 30 with the tier 4 finish now established, the 2026 trajectory is sustained tier 4-5 production.

McKivitz came out of West Virginia as San Francisco's 5th-round pick (153rd overall) in 2020. He spent his first three NFL seasons as a swing-tackle backup behind Trent Williams and Mike McGlinchey, then stepped into the starting right tackle role full-time in 2023 when McGlinchey left for Denver. Three straight finishes at right tackle (#52 in 2023, #47 in 2024, #29 in 2025) show steady year-over-year improvement, with the 2025 jump to tier 4 confirming the role is locked.

Comps

Built like: Michael Deiter, Jarrett Patterson, Travis Frederick.

Colton McKivitz Injury StatusNot listed

Colton McKivitz is not on the injury report as of Nov 22. Source: the official NFL injury report, refreshed daily.

This season · 7 games

Pass Protection78.813th
Run Blocking66.115th
Overall Grade74.910th

Every game on the Game Log, every season on Career. Advanced numbers are EPA and Next Gen Stats.

Contract2026 cap

2026 Cap Hit
$5.8M
APY
$15.0M/yr
Guaranteed at Signing
$18.7M
Years on Deal
4
Signed
2025
Est. Value
$24.8M/yr
underpaid by $9.8M/yr

Every year of the deal, the dead money and what a cut or trade saves on the Contract tab.

Draft & College

Round 5, pick 153 to the San Francisco 49ers in 2020, out of W VIRGINIA (Unknown). He went about where consensus had him.

Taken#153
Consensus board127th
Our college model#41 OT

Coming out: 5.35s 40 yd, 20 reps bench, 26" vertical, 106" broad, 7.87s 3-cone, 5s shuttle.

Related Tools & Pages